Showing posts with label essay. Show all posts
Showing posts with label essay. Show all posts

1/11/12

Throwing the Canon Overboard

I am not a literature person.

Theoretically, I should be. I love books, I love to read, I love to write, and I love to appreciate good writing. But damn, I'm an English major, if that tells you anything.

But I just don't enjoy literature.

One of my professors loves to emphasize the pleasure of the literary canon. He describes the thrill of reading a story with the knowledge that thousands, tens of thousands of others have read it before you, the low hum of satisfaction in finding meaning in it, a meaning fractionally shared with that multiplicity of other people.

I've never felt that with the literary canon myself.

I pick up a book from the literary canon and I get through it, annoyed all the way, and wanting to brutally murder the narrator with a tea kettle by the end. For what I can gather, the main feature of canonical literature is a whiny-ass main character. Hamlet, Winston, Bernard, Frankenstein, Heathcliff.... Allow me to use my mastery of the English language to paraphrase these characters: "Bitch bitch bitch."

I'll grant that I enjoyed A Clockwork Orange and One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest, and while I can't say I took pleasure in A Confederacy of Dunces, I did appreciate the masterful use of satire and footnotes (I really loved the wonderful break from Ignatius that the footnotes offered). And after spending a month researching paganism in Tess of the D'Urbervilles, I finally developed a sort of begrudging respect for the work.

But, on the whole, I don't really enjoy those texts that are typically defined as literature.

Listening to my professor describe the buzz one derives from literature, I realize that I have felt it before - while watching Buffy the Vampire Slayer. And again, while streaming Dr. Horrible's Sing-Along Blog. And yet again, when I was tearing through the series Firefly, and later the film Serenity. I've felt it while watching Amélie for the six-billionth time, and when I was first introduced to Dr. Who, and How I Met Your Mother. I experienced it when I first discovered Anne McCaffrey's sci-fi/fantasy vision of Pern way back in elementary school, and when I took the time to peruse my first Draco/Hermione fanfic. The thrill of reading raced through my system when my best friend loaned me a few short novels by Amelia Atwater-Rhodes, and again when I plucked Kim Harrison's Dead Witch Walking off a bookstore shelf. I spent hours poring over Christopher Moore's re-interpretation of King Lear, although I believe the power of the play to be greatly lost with Fool's very altered ending. Sarah Dessen's Just Listen continues to fascinate me, six years after I first laid hands on it.

Make no mistake. I've felt the "inherent pleasure" of literature. I've found the critical processes of English to be deeply beneficial, even natural, to me - when applying those methods to just about anything other than the standard canon. Literary criticism and analysis focused on Buffy are the main component of my "for fun" reading (I can't decide if Rhonda Wilcox or Joss Whedon is my biggest hero), and I frequently find myself drafting a mini-analysis for just about any text that crosses my interest. I love being an English major.

But I am not a literature person.


Well, not unless you'll let me throw the canon overboard.

5/30/11

Paganism as an Alternative to Victorian-ism in Tess of the D'Urbervilles

The Victorian period is generally invoked as an era of strict morals, exaggerated class distinctions, and sexual repression - overall, an epoch of artificiality and appearances. Thomas Hardy, among other authors and artists of the time, objected to the censorship that these strict sensibilities imposed. In his Tess of the D'Urbervilles, Hardy uses elements of paganism as a direct contrast to the unnaturalness of the Victorian rules, values, and morals that are featured in the novel. Throughout the course of the narration, this is obvious in Tess's sexuality and spirituality and in how others perceive her.

Hardy opens the novel by showing the village "club walking," a sort of Christianized version of the pagan holiday Beltane, traditionally a celebration of fertility: "In addition to the distinction of a white frock, every woman and girl carried in her right hand a peeled willow wand and in her left a bunch of white flowers" (8). The white dress symbolizes Tess's innocence, while the flowers and the wand respectively represent the pagan Goddess and God. The ceremony indicates the persistence of the older, more natural religion, and thus sexuality, within and despite the staid confines of Victorian Christianity. However, Tess is unaware of the origins of the festival, much as she is unaware of her own sensuality. When Alec bedecks her with strawberries and flowers (much like a High Priestess would be dressed in elaborate nature costumes for a ceremony), she becomes "aware of the spectacle she presented to their surprised vision" upon returning to the public eye (39). Pamela Jekel writes that Tess's acceptance of Alec's costuming is "the clearest note of Tess's [sexual] ambiguity... obviously a symbol of nature forced before its natural ripening..." (169). The implication is that Tess is not just pagan, but symbolic of nature in and of itself. And what, in an age that valued industrialization and urbanization, was more outside conventions than nature? Even her later rape-seduction at Alec's hands seems to imply the same sort of relationship between she and Alec as the earth and industrialized society- as much as Tess and the earth give, Alec and mankind persist in taking. However, one cannot say that Alec's attraction to Tess is unrequited; Hardy makes numerous references to how flattered Tess is by his attentions and to how captivated she is by his looks. He seems to imply "that the physical attraction that Tess feels toward Alec is natural," urging "exclusion from the sphere of moral judgement. In a less artificial world Tess might have regarded her relationship with Alec as a freely available option" (Ingham 146). This "less artifical world" could be something like the earlier world, when paganism was predominant, or our modern world, where paganism and the sensuality traditionally associated with it are re-emerging.

When Tess returns to Marlott, Hardy emphasizes that she is the one who has been wronged rather than the one in the wrong by exploring her spiritual life. To escape the condemnation of her mother and other neighbors, Tess begins to spend time outside, communing with nature much as a practicing pagan would, where
                   she looked upon herself as a figure of Guilt intruding 
                   into the haunts of Innocence. But all the while, she was 
                   making a distinction where there was no difference. 
                   Feeling herself in antagonism, she was quite in accord. 
                   She had been made to break an accepted social law, 
                   but no law known to the environment in which she 
                   fancied herself such an anomaly. (85)
This clearly expresses that in natural, or pagan, circumstances Tess has committed no crime. Hardy is saying that it is only society, specifically Victorian society, that thinks of sex as wrong or immoral. When her un-baptized son, the aptly named Sorrow, falls ill slightly later in the narrative, Hardy has Tess baptize him herself, a scene which in its spontaneity bears remarkable similarity to a spell a modern-day pagan might perform. "Tess stood erect with the infant on her arm beside the basin... and thus the girl set about baptizing her child... The children gazed up at her with... reverence... She did not look like Sissy to them now, but as a being large, towering and awful - a divine personage..." (94-95). In bypassing the structure of the Church, Tess employs the pagan principle of communing directly with the divine and, in doing so, becomes divine herself. Patricia Ingham makes the additional note that the midnight baptism is not only a reflection on the over-involvement of the clergy of the Anglican Church in personal spiritual matters, but an indictment of the stigma that Victorian morality insisted on attaching to children born out of wedlock. "Hardy is moving towards beliefs subversive of the whole of established society as constructed by the State, the Church, and other institutions" (Ingham 146-147). Before moving on to the next phase of Tess's life, Hardy makes the final commentary, "She became... a woman whom the turbulent experiences of the last year... had quite failed to demoralize. But for the world's opinion those experiences would have been simply a liberal education" (99). In other words, what Tess has done and been through should be viewed far from being as scandalous as Victorian sensibilities would have us consider them; they should be regarded as necessary and beneficial to her development as a human being.

It is important to note how Tess's unflagging positive attitude, especially where Victorian society would have her downtrodden or ashamed, affects the way she is perceived. It is this attitude, this fortitude and persistence of character, which allows the reader to sympathize with Tess rather than detest her. It is not long after her infant's death that Tess, in response to her family's financial needs, departs Marlott to go work at Talbothay's dairy. it is at Talbothay's that Tess meets Angel Clare, a parson's son, who, though a well-read and philosophical man, has chosen to go into agriculture rather than religion. He notes "what a fresh and virginal daughter of nature [Tess] is" (121). In Victorian terms, this is merely ironic, but when regarded through the perspective of paganism, it is one of the most apt statements made about Tess in the course of the novel. She is a virgin in the same way Nature is virginal - her virginity is self-renewing. Although she has been seduced, she is still an innocent, mostly thanks to her positive attitude. Later, when exploring their mutual attraction, Angel perceives her in an even more pagan sense - as a goddess. "She was... a whole sex condensed into one typical form. He called her Artemis, Demeter, and other fanciful names..." (131). The two marry before Tess divulges her previous involvement with Alec. When she comes out with it, Angel, despite his attempts at freethinking and an affair of his own, is disgusted with her. Hardy reveals here one of the double-standards of Victorian society, typified by a divorce law which allowed a man to "divorce his wife for even a single act of adultery; [whereas] a wife needed to prove not only adultery by her husband but also some aggravating factor such as incest, bigamy, sodomy, bestiality, or extreme cruelty" (Ingham 57). He abandons Tess, becoming "the slave to custom and conventionality..." (267). But this only reveals yet another of Tess's pagan qualities: despite Angel's abandonment, her family's financial straits, and her own needs and hardships, she remains loyal to him and continues to work for his betterment, just as nature remains faithful to and continues to work for man. "The essence of goodness that such a devotion implies" serves to reprimand both Angel and the society that approves his actions (Jekel 160). However, Tess is human; faced with her family's homelessness and finally despairing of Angel's return, she allows the still persistent Alec to support her and whisk her off to the city.

Angel eventually rethinks and casts off the fetters of Victorian-ism in favor of more natural pagan standards, much as Hardy would have his readers do. "The old appraisements of morality... wanted readjusting... The beauty or ugliness of a character lay... not among things done, but among things willed" (348). Making Tess, a woman who never set out to offend anyone, above reproach: it is only the unnatural societal standards she is held to that paint her as a villain. Angel returns for her, and the two proceed to spend several days on the run, until Tess is arrested at Stonehenge for Alec's murder, and is summarily hanged. This can be interpreted as poetic justice since she gets what Victorian sensibilities would see as her just desserts - she, a pagan, is 'sacrificed' on a pagan altar - but it also serves as an indictment of a society that, with its unnatural expectations, drives an innocent woman to her death. Yes, Tess is a sacrifice - but it is Victorian sensibilities doing the sacrificing.




Works Cited

  • Casey, Ellen Miller. "'Other People's Prudery': Mary Elizabeth Braddon." Literature Resource Center. Vol. 111. Detroit: Gale Group, 2001. web. 7 April 2010.
  • Cohen, William A. "Sex, Scandal, and the Novel." The Victorian Web. Duke University, 1996. Web. 7 April 2010.
  • Hardy, Thomas. Tess of the D'Urbervilles. New York City, New York: Signet Classic, 1999. Print.
  • Ingham, Patricia. Thomas Hardy. New York: Oxford University Press, 2003. Print.
  • Jekel, Pamela L. "Tess Durbeyfield." Thomas Hardy's Heroines: A Chorus of Priorities. United States: Pamela Jekel, 1986. 156-177. Print.

Heroism in Dr. Horrible's Sing-Along Blog

Despite only totaling 45 minutes in length, Joss Whedon's Dr. Horrible's Sing-Along Blog is an exceedingly rich film. One of the many themes explored in the musical is the question of what makes a hero. Three paradigms of heroism are presented in the persons of the "worst villain ever," Dr. Horrible, "Justice's other name," Captain Hammer, and their mutual love interest, Penny.

Although the titular character, Dr. Horrible, is consistently referred to as a villain, his motivations and methods make him less a model of an evil genius than of a revolutionary. The mad scientist figure only wants to "change the world" - and get the cute girl from the laundromat (Penny) to notice him. Unable to overcome his awkwardness to either work within the political system to improve the world he despairs of ("Any dolt with half a brain can see that human kind has gone insane") or to speak to the girl he desperately longs to have a "real, audible connection" with, he turns instead to the building of a trans-matter ray to steal gold bars out of a bank vault and a freeze ray to stop time so he can "find the time to find the words" to talk to Penny. Dr. Horrible represents the extreme but good-intentioned hero, overlooked but powerful in his own right.

In contrast, his nemesis, "Captain Hammer - Captain Hammer, corporate tool," represents the celebrity hero, lauded by the system and motivated less by the opportunity to improve the world than by the fame and women that come attached. In his memorable introductory scene, Captain Hammer foils Dr. Horrible's van heist, announcing "Captain Hammer's here, hair blowing in the breeze - the day needs my saving expertise." This expertise calls for the hero to punch and destroy the device Dr. Horrible is using to control the van, before abandoning the careening vehicle in order to flirt with a cute female bystander, proudly informing her that, "the only doom that's looming is you loving me to death." The viewer's opinion of Captain Hammer and what the city perceives as his heroics only diminishes as he is shown wiping off his hand after being greeted by a homeless man, cruelly mocking Dr. Horrible with his relationship with Penny, and beating up an unarmed Dr. Horrible (pausing so a tourist can get a picture), culminating in his horrifyingly satirical number, "Everyone's a Hero." Set at the dedication of a homeless shelter, the song, sung in lieu of a speech, informs enraptured citizens in the audience that they're all heroes in their own ways as they've "all got villains they must face," and if those villains are not as cool as his then "it's fine to know your place" before assuring them that if they're "not a frigging 'tard" they "will prevail."

The third paradigm of heroism is shown in the the "quiet, nerdy" Penny. Called neither a hero nor a villain, Penny is the Every Man character, dressed in colorful clothes where Dr. Horrible and Captain Hammer wear either black or white. But while the two men spend the duration of the musical squabbling over her, Penny is dedicatedly working with the homeless, making a small but tangible difference in the world when she successfully campaigns to get the city to donate a condemned building as a new homeless shelter. However, Dr. Horrible dismisses her efforts as "treating a symptom while the disease rages on" and Captain Hammer engages in her cause only because he "might just sleep with the same girl twice." Penny represents the sincere, everyday hero, unacknowledged as she works within the political system to improve society, aspiring not to rule the world ala Dr. Horrible or garner fame ala Captain Hammer, but to be "hope." Indeed, the crowning tragedy of the film is that Penny is killed in the midst of Captain Hammer and Dr. Horrible's power struggle, and is summarily ignored by the press as "Whats-Her-Name" and "Heroes Girlfriend, (sic)" representing the ways in which our society overlooks similar heroic figures.

Whereas Dr. Horrible embodies an extreme hero working outside the system and Captain Hammer personifies a hero so integrated into the system he has ceased to be effective, only Penny's brand of heroism, using the system to further her ends, seems to get results, thus answering the question of what makes a hero.